Xem thêm

Ducted vs. Ductless Air Conditioning Systems: Making the Right Choice for Your Home

CEO Khai Intela
Air conditioning is a crucial factor to consider when dealing with residential or commercial buildings. Whether you're renovating your house or designing your dream home, choosing between a ductless system and a ducted one can...

Air conditioning is a crucial factor to consider when dealing with residential or commercial buildings. Whether you're renovating your house or designing your dream home, choosing between a ductless system and a ducted one can be overwhelming. In this guide, we will explore the basics of these systems, along with their advantages and disadvantages, to help you make an informed decision about the best option for your home.

Ducted Air Conditioning Systems

Ducted vs. Ductless Air Conditioning Systems

Ducted air conditioning systems deliver heating or cooling through a network of ducts that spread throughout your home or commercial space. A central unit, consisting of a condenser, compressor, and an air handling unit, is usually located in the basement, attic, or garage. It provides cool or hot air, which is then distributed through a series of ducts and vents, ensuring the appropriate climate control throughout the building.

Types of Ducted Air Conditioning Systems

Ducted systems, also known as central air conditioning systems, can be broadly divided into two types: split central air conditioners and packaged central air conditioners.

Split Central Air Conditioners

Ducted vs. Ductless Air Conditioning Systems

Split central air conditioners are the most common type of central air conditioning system used today. They consist of an outdoor condenser and compressor unit packaged together and placed outside. The indoor evaporator unit is located in a segregated container, typically in a closet or attic. The outdoor unit supplies refrigerant to the evaporator, which cools the air and delivers it through the central air ducts via an air handling unit.

Split central air conditioners are about three times the size of equivalent packaged central air conditioners, making them more manageable. They also have higher SEER ratings (Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ratio) compared to packaged air conditioners. In many split-system air conditioners, the indoor unit also contains a furnace or heat exchanger, making them an economical option for homes with existing furnace ductwork.

Packaged Central Air Conditioners

Ducted vs. Ductless Air Conditioning Systems

In packaged central air conditioners, all components, including the condenser, compressor, and evaporator, are contained in a single unit. This unit can be installed on a concrete slab next to your house or on the roof. Packaged central air conditioning systems are ideal for commercial buildings or pre-built homes with limited indoor space. These systems can also be coupled with heating coils or furnaces to provide heating.

Before opting for packaged central systems, it's essential to assess your outdoor space and ensure it can support the weight. If placed on the ground, concrete emplacements need to be prepared in advance. Additionally, consider the impact on your indoor space as central air ducts take up a significant amount of room. Evaluate if a ducted system aligns with your home's layout and design.

Types of Ducts for Ducted Heating or Cooling

Ducting is a crucial component of central air conditioning systems. There are two main types of ducts used in ducted air conditioning systems:

1. Flexible Ducting

Ducted vs. Ductless Air Conditioning Systems

Flexible ducting consists of a metal framework surrounded by flexible plastic and insulation. These tube-like structures with a large diameter are cost-effective and easy to install, making them suitable for confined spaces. Flexible ducting is often used to connect rigid ductwork to air outlets. Ensure there are no kinks or bends during installation to maintain proper airflow.

2. Rigid Ducting

Ducted vs. Ductless Air Conditioning Systems

Rigid ducting is composed of fixed metal structures that distribute air throughout the space. While sturdier and more durable than flexible ducts, they are harder to install and tend to be noisier. Fiberglass insulation can be used to reduce noise, but it may pose health risks if deteriorating or old. Proper maintenance is essential to prevent allergic reactions or irritation.

Pros and Cons of Ducted Air Conditioning

Let's take a closer look at the pros and cons of ducted air conditioning systems:

Pros Cons
Existing ductwork Higher installation costs in already built properties
Unobtrusive and discrete Lower efficiency and potential leaks in ducts
Effective humidity control Maintenance-intensive with regular upkeep
Enhanced airflow for large spaces Mold and contaminants in ducts can cause allergies and diseases

Ductless Air Conditioning Systems

Ducted vs. Ductless Air Conditioning Systems

Ductless air conditioning systems provide cooling without the need for ductwork. These systems consist of an outdoor unit and an indoor air-handling unit with an evaporator coil and fan. A copper conduit connects the outdoor and indoor units, housing the power cable, condensate drain, refrigerant tubing, and suction tubing.

Types of Ductless Air Conditioning Systems

Ductless air conditioners offer various types, from conventional to smart varieties. Let's explore some of the major types:

Wall Mounted Mini Splits

Ducted vs. Ductless Air Conditioning Systems

Wall-mounted mini-splits are versatile and easy to install. These units can be placed high on the wall, ensuring effective air circulation. They are cost-effective and provide the flexibility of zone control, allowing users to set individual room temperatures. Modern advancements also enable these units to work as reversible heat pumps, providing heating during winter months.

Window Units

Ducted vs. Ductless Air Conditioning Systems

Window units combine the evaporator and condenser in a single housing, installed on a window. They are suitable for smaller spaces or individual rooms and offer adequate cooling.

Portable Air Conditioners

Ducted vs. Ductless Air Conditioning Systems

Portable air conditioners are convenient as they can be placed anywhere, providing cooling as needed. These units are lightweight and have a hose for venting hot air.

Ducted Mini-Splits

Ducted mini-splits provide the advantages of both ducted and ductless systems. These units connect to ducts that distribute cooled or warmed air throughout the space. The ducts connect to barely visible grills or registers in each room.

Floor Mounted Mini-Splits

Floor-mounted mini-splits are placed close to the floor, making them suitable for rooms with low-hanging ceilings or limited wall space. They are also ideal for rooms with large windows that restrict wall-mounted unit installation.

Cassette Type Air Conditioners

Ducted vs. Ductless Air Conditioning Systems

Cassette air conditioners are recessed within the ceiling, maintaining room aesthetics. These units provide airflow from multiple openings, making them suitable for large spaces like shopping stores or workspaces.

Pros and Cons of Ductless Air Conditioning

Let's weigh the pros and cons of ductless air conditioning systems:

Pros Cons
Minimal space requirement Visible indoor units can be obtrusive
Individual temperature control Higher initial installation costs
Increasing utility rebates Limited airflow compared to ducted systems
Inverter technology for energy efficiency Better air quality with no ducts carrying dust and contaminants

When to Opt for Ducted Air Conditioning

While both options have their merits, there are specific situations where a ducted air conditioning system is the better choice:

  1. Existing ducts: If your home already has ductwork, utilizing it can be cost-effective.
  2. Humid spaces: Ducted air conditioning systems excel at controlling humidity, making them ideal for moist regions.
  3. Improved airflow: Ducted systems provide better air circulation, making them suitable for large spaces.
  4. Discreet solution: Ducted systems are aesthetically pleasing, with the main components hidden from view.
  5. Low-maintenance: Ducted systems require less maintenance compared to ductless units, making them a convenient option.

When to Opt for Ductless Air Conditioning

Ductless air conditioning systems are the preferred choice in certain circumstances:

  1. No room for ducts: If installing ductwork is not an option, ductless systems are a practical choice.
  2. Additional spaces: Adding rooms or needing extra heating/cooling in specific areas can be achieved more affordably with ductless systems.
  3. Avoid dust: Ductless systems deliver air directly into living spaces, minimizing the chances of dust and contaminants.
  4. Multiple zone control: Ductless systems allow individual temperature control in each room, making them ideal for shared spaces and accommodating personal preferences.

Combining Ducted and Ductless Systems

Another option is to have a combination of ducted and ductless systems, known as ducted ductless cooling. This provides the benefits of both systems, allowing for added cooling in spaces where ductwork is impractical or costly. It offers zoning and integrated controls for HVAC, providing flexibility.

Which Is Better: Ducted or Ductless Air Conditioning?

The choice between ducted and ductless air conditioning depends on specific needs and considerations. Factors such as existing installation, space requirements, budget, zonal control, and maintenance requirements play a significant role in making the best decision for your home. Assessing these factors will help you determine the most suitable air conditioning system for your needs.

Final Thoughts

Deciding between ducted and ductless air conditioning systems is not a simple task. Consider your unique needs, weigh the advantages and disadvantages, and ensure the chosen system aligns with your budget and home layout. By making an informed decision, you can achieve the comfort, efficiency, and convenience you desire. Happy hunting!

1